Keeping Score in Marriage
By Eddie Eccker, MS, LMFT
Why both of you can feel unseen when both of you are working hard
One spouse says, "I've been with the kids all day. I haven't had a minute to myself."
The other answers, "I know. I've been working all day, and I walked in the door to a list of things that still need to be done."
Neither one is exaggerating. Both are tired. A few sentences later they are arguing about who worked harder and whose exhaustion counts the most.
On the surface the argument is about dishes or bedtime, who gets more free time and so on. Underneath it, each person is asking something more painful: do you see what it costs me to keep our life going?
That question deserves an answer. The trouble starts when a couple uses their need to be seen or their struggle as the way they decide what is fair.
Why your own work feels bigger
We experience our own work from the inside. We know how many decisions we made before breakfast, what we put aside to meet someone else's need, and how little energy was left when we did one more thing anyway.
We see our spouse's work from the outside. We see the result, or only the part that is still undone.
A spouse who earns most of the income feels the pressure of the mortgage payment and wonders whether anyone appreciates it. A spouse who manages appointments, school messages, meals, and the emotional state of the house wonders whether any of that registers as work. A parent who has been home with young children all day needs relief the moment the other parent walks in. The parent walking in needs a few minutes to recover before being needed again.
Each of them is telling the truth about their own day and missing most of the other person's.
Once someone feels unseen, they start presenting evidence. They list tasks, hours, and sacrifices. Their spouse answers with a list of their own. The lists get longer and neither person feels more understood, because by then each of them is defending their own worth.
When one of you is having a harder time
Sometimes one spouse really is in a harder season. Illness, grief, depression, an overwhelming job, or the demands of caring for a child change what a person is able to carry. A loving marriage makes room for that. Fair does not always mean splitting every task down the middle.
Still, being in pain does not decide who does what. "I'm struggling" tells your spouse that you need care. It does not tell either of you which arrangement is sustainable or which commitments each of you can keep.
The same goes for sacrifice. "I've done so much for this family" can be true, and it needs to be acknowledged. It cannot be the end of a conversation about what the family needs now.
Either statement can be used to shut the conversation down, and when it is, the other spouse hears a tactic instead of a need.
Couples get stuck when they ask one conversation to do three jobs at once: recognize effort, respond to distress, and decide how to divide the work.
Three questions to take one at a time
The first question is "Do you see me?"
Before you negotiate chores or defend your own contribution, find out what your spouse believes has gone unnoticed. Recognition has to be specific. "I know you're busy" lands very differently from "I see that you handled the school calls, rearranged your afternoon, and still made dinner."
The second question is "What do you need?"
Someone who is overwhelmed might need rest, help with one particular task, more affection, or a change in how the week is planned. Appreciation alone will not solve a practical problem. Ask what would actually help.
The third question is "What is fair for us to do?"
This one takes an honest look at capacity, agreements, finances, time, and the work that has to get done. The answer might be a different division of labor. It might be outside help, a lower standard in one area, or an agreement to revisit the arrangement when a hard season passes.
There are also times when the split really is unfair. When it is, I commonly find that each spouse defends their position as if the complaint were an attack on their identity, their intentions, or their heart. Sometimes things are just not fair, and a couple has to accept that as part of life before they can do anything about it. Once both of you can say "this is lopsided right now" without hearing it as an accusation, you can start moving, where you can, toward some kind of equity. Some couples will not get to even and will only get to better.
Answering one of these does not answer the others. You can appreciate your spouse and still need the arrangement to change. Asking for help does not mean your spouse's work counts for less.
Stop asking whose contribution matters more
Different kinds of work are hard to compare. An hour at a paid job and an hour with a sick child are both hours, and that tells you very little about the strain, responsibility, or flexibility involved. Couples who try to prove that one kind of work is worth more end up arguing about status, and the problem they share goes unsolved.
It helps to say so out loud:
"I think we're both trying to prove how much we're carrying, and I don't want either of us to have to do that. Can we go through what each of us is actually doing and what's wearing us down, and then figure out what needs to change?"
You will probably still disagree, but each of you will have been heard before you are asked to negotiate.
Marriage includes seasons when one person carries more. It also includes work that is hard to see unless someone takes the time to ask. A healthy couple can name both without turning a hard season into a permanent claim against the other.
If the two of you are keeping score, start by asking yourself two things. What am I carrying that my spouse does not see? What is my spouse carrying that I have stopped noticing? Then talk about what each of you needs and make a plan you can both live with.
Couples counseling across the Front Range
Voyages Counseling works with couples, individuals, teens, and families. We see clients in person at our offices in Centennial, Lone Tree, Castle Rock, Central Park Denver, and Colorado Springs, and by telehealth anywhere in Colorado.
If the two of you keep having this argument and cannot get past it on your own, a couples counselor can help you have it differently.
We offer a free phone consultation so you can ask questions and get a sense of whether we would be a good fit before committing to anything.
(720) 729-7372
voyagescounseling.com
This post is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for professional mental health care. If you are in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.
Comments